Earthborn Holistic vs Solid Gold

Two independent natural mid-tier brands. Earthborn Holistic is made by Midwestern Pet Foods (whose parent had a 2020 aflatoxin recall on the Sportmix line, not Earthborn directly); Solid Gold uses co-manufacturers.

Earthborn Holistic

Average score: 64/100. 19 products. Country: US.

Solid Gold

Average score: 67/100. 32 products. Country: US.

Verdict

Overall scores are close — Earthborn Holistic averages 64/100 vs Solid Gold at 67/100. Catalog breadth: Solid Gold (32 products) is broader than the smaller line (19).